Here’s a detailed blog post about each player from the 1972 Topps All-Star Rookie Team. This lineup boasts Hall of Famers, All-Stars, and standout players who defined baseball in the 1970s and beyond.
Carlton Fisk – C – Red Sox
Nicknamed “Pudge,” Carlton Fisk was one of baseball’s premier catchers, known for his leadership and longevity. Fisk’s career spanned 24 seasons with the Red Sox and White Sox, during which he recorded a .269 batting average, 376 home runs, and 1,330 RBIs. Fisk’s iconic moment came in the 1975 World Series when he hit a dramatic, game-winning home run in Game 6, famously waving the ball fair. An 11-time All-Star and Hall of Famer, Fisk remains celebrated for his contributions to the game and his competitive spirit.
Tom Hutton – 1B – Phillies
Tom Hutton was a valuable role player and an outstanding defender at first base, especially known for his ability to hit well against Hall of Famer Tom Seaver. Over his 12-year career, Hutton batted .248 with 22 home runs and 186 RBIs. Primarily a defensive specialist, Hutton contributed to the Phillies, Dodgers, and Blue Jays with his consistent glove work and occasional power. After retiring, he became a respected broadcaster, beloved by fans for his insights and baseball knowledge.
Jack Brohamer – 2B – Indians
Jack Brohamer was a steady second baseman who played 10 seasons in the major leagues. Known for his defensive skills, he hit .245 with 30 home runs and 227 RBIs. Brohamer is remembered for his unique place in baseball history as the only player to hit a cycle in a White Sox uniform. He contributed to several teams, including the Indians, White Sox, and Red Sox, providing reliable infield depth and veteran presence.
Dave Roberts – 3B – Padres
Dave Roberts had a productive 10-year career, mostly with the Padres, where he made his mark as a versatile infielder. With a .239 career batting average, 49 home runs, and 208 RBIs, Roberts was primarily a third baseman but also played second and first base.
he later spent time as a minor league manager, helping develop the next generation of players.
Dwain Anderson – SS – Athletics
Dwain Anderson, known for his defensive skills at shortstop, played four seasons in MLB with a .203 career batting average, four home runs, and 19 RBIs. Anderson contributed to several teams, including the Athletics, Cardinals, and Padres. he made a mark with his slick fielding and reliable glove.
Don Baylor – OF – Orioles
Don Baylor was known for his power at the plate and his tough, aggressive playing style. Over his 19-year career, Baylor hit .260 with 338 home runs and 1,276 RBIs. Baylor won the 1979 AL MVP, leading the league in hit-by-pitches multiple times. He later transitioned to managing, bringing his leadership and experience to the dugout.
Buddy Bell – 3B – Indians
Buddy Bell, a five-time All-Star and six-time Gold Glove winner, was one of the best defensive third basemen of his era. Over 18 seasons, he batted .279 with 201 home runs and 1,106 RBIs. Known for his consistency and baseball IQ, Bell enjoyed a successful career with the Indians, Rangers, and Reds. After his playing days, he became a manager and executive, continuing his family’s baseball legacy and contributing to the game in multiple capacities.
Garry Maddox – OF – Phillies
Nicknamed “The Secretary of Defense,” Garry Maddox was known for his exceptional range and defensive prowess in center field. A two-time All-Star and eight-time Gold Glove winner, Maddox batted .285 with 117 home runs and 754 RBIs over 15 seasons. He played a key role for the Phillies, particularly during their 1980 World Series championship run. Maddox’s stellar fielding and speed on the bases made him a fan favorite.
Dick Tidrow – P – Indians
Dick Tidrow, a reliable pitcher with a bulldog mentality, played 13 seasons in the major leagues. Known for his versatility, Tidrow was effective as both a starter and reliever, finishing with a 100-94 record, a 3.68 ERA, and 55 saves. He pitched for several teams and won two World Series titles with the Yankees in 1977 and 1978. After retiring, Tidrow worked as a talent evaluator and executive, helping the Giants build their championship-winning rosters in the 2010s.
Jon Matlack – P – Mets
Jon Matlack was a three-time All-Star and the 1972 NL Rookie of the Year. Over his 13-year career, Matlack posted a 125-126 record with a 3.18 ERA and 1,023 strikeouts. Matlack was a key figure in the Mets’ rotation in the 1970s. His best years came with the Mets, where he formed a formidable rotation alongside Tom Seaver and Jerry Koosman. Matlack later pitched for the Texas Rangers, where he remained a steady presence until his retirement.
This group from the 1972 Topps All-Star Rookie Team includes players who left a lasting impact on the game through their performances, leadership, and love for baseball. From Fisk’s legendary home run to Baylor’s MVP season, these players made contributions that fans remember.